from the pass —
Menu photos
A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.
1 / 2
Discover the Goodfellas Pizza menu featuring flavorful pizzas, fresh salads, garlic knots, and wings. Enjoy friendly service and great prices at 1 Hewitt St, Amsterdam, NY.
Introducing the menu at Goodfellas Pizza, located in Amsterdam, NY, a local favorite known for its perfectly balanced pies. Their pizza strikes an ideal harmony—crusts are not too thick, with flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese, creating a satisfying bite every time. Beyond pizza, the menu shines with crowd-pleasers like their famous garlic knots, praised for their perfect texture and irresistible flavor, as well as generous house salads loaded with fresh, crisp greens and vibrant toppings. Fans rave about the wings, calling them the best around, while unique options such as the chicken Alfredo pizza add variety and depth to the offerings. Customers consistently highlight the friendly service and reliable delivery, making it a comfortable choice for dine-in, takeout, or delivery. Goodfellas Pizza impresses with great food at fair prices, inviting everyone to savor authentic, well-crafted dishes that keep local and new customers coming back.
A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.
Tried this place tonight for take out. Would highly recommend. The pizza was great. Not too thick. Sauce had good flavor and enough cheese on it . Very good
Opening hours, the full address and the best way to get there are all on the restaurant page. Booking policies differ from place to place — so call ahead, or simply walk in.